#!/usr/bin/env python3 """ PST Computation 5 — Stage 4 of the 10-foundational programme ============================================================================ Newton's constant from the spectral action principle, replacing the Kaluza-Klein dimensional-reduction identity (which is meaningless once the three compact spatial dimensions are gone in the 10-foundational reading). The bosonic spectral action of a spectral triple is S = Tr f(D / Lambda), f a positive cutoff function, Lambda a cutoff scale. Its heat-kernel asymptotic expansion in 4 dimensions is (Chamseddine-Connes 1996; Chamseddine-Connes-Marcolli 2007) S ~ 2 f_4 Lambda^4 a_0 + 2 f_2 Lambda^2 a_2 + f_0 a_4 + O(Lambda^-2), with moments f_2 = int_0^inf u f(u) du, f_4 = int_0^inf u^3 f(u) du, f_0 = f(0), and a_{2k} the Seeley-DeWitt coefficients of D^2. The terms are: Lambda^4 a_0 -> cosmological constant (+ volume), Lambda^2 a_2 -> EINSTEIN-HILBERT (1/16 pi G) int R sqrt(g) d^4x, Lambda^0 a_4 -> Yang-Mills + Higgs + Weyl^2 (the SM bosonic sector). So gravity is not put in by hand and not obtained by Kaluza-Klein reduction; the Einstein-Hilbert term is the Lambda^2 coefficient of the universal spectral action, with 1 / (16 pi G) = (f_2 Lambda^2 / pi^2) * kappa_grav * N_dof, kappa_grav an O(1) scheme constant (the exact CCM normalisation is 1/kappa_0^2 = (96 f_2 Lambda^2 - f_0 c)/(24 pi^2), kappa_0^2 = 8 pi G, c a Yukawa trace), N_dof the fermionic multiplicity of the internal space. What this script checks (order-of-magnitude / structural, not precision): M1 The cutoff moments f_0, f_2, f_4 are finite positive numbers for a sample f (here f(u) = e^{-u}): the cutoff supplies finite constants. M2 G ~ 1/(f_2 Lambda^2 N_dof): solving for Lambda given the observed G and the SM fermion count puts Lambda at a high (unification/Planck-ish) scale, the recognisable CCM result. Gravity's weakness = a high cutoff. M3 Dimensional consistency and the replacement of the KK identity. Run: python3 computation_05.py """ import numpy as np from math import gamma, pi, sqrt SEP = "=" * 78 def hdr(s): print(f"\n{SEP}\n {s}\n{SEP}") print(SEP) print(" PST Computation 5 — Newton's G from the spectral action (Stage 4)") print(SEP) # ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── # §1. Cutoff moments are finite positive constants # ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── hdr("§1 — Cutoff moments f_0, f_2, f_4 (sample f(u) = e^{-u})") print(""" The spectral action needs a positive cutoff f with finite moments f_2 = int_0^inf u f(u) du, f_4 = int_0^inf u^3 f(u) du, f_0 = f(0). For f(u) = e^{-u}: f_k = int_0^inf u^{k-1} e^{-u} du = Gamma(k), and f_0 = 1. These are the finite constants that set the action coefficients. """) # numeric integration as a cross-check on the closed forms Gamma(k) _trapz = getattr(np, "trapezoid", getattr(np, "trapz", None)) u = np.linspace(0, 60, 600001) f = np.exp(-u) f2_num = _trapz(u * f, u) # int u f f4_num = _trapz(u**3 * f, u) # int u^3 f f0 = 1.0 print(f" f_2 = int u e^-u du = {f2_num:.5f} (closed form Gamma(2) = {gamma(2):.5f})") print(f" f_4 = int u^3 e^-u du = {f4_num:.5f} (closed form Gamma(4) = {gamma(4):.5f})") print(f" f_0 = f(0) = {f0:.5f}") print(f" all finite and positive: {f2_num>0 and f4_num>0 and f0>0}") # ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── # §2. G ~ 1/(f_2 Lambda^2 N): the cutoff scale that reproduces gravity # ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── hdr("§2 — Solving 1/(16 pi G) ~ (f_2 Lambda^2/pi^2) kappa N for Lambda") print(""" The Einstein-Hilbert coefficient gives M_P^2 = 1/G ~ f_2 Lambda^2 N_dof (up to O(1) scheme constants). Inverting: the cutoff Lambda that reproduces the observed Newton constant is Lambda ~ M_P / sqrt(kappa * N_dof). We use the reduced Planck mass and the CCM fermionic multiplicity of one generation embedded in the full count. """) M_P_reduced = 2.435e18 # GeV, reduced Planck mass (1/sqrt(8 pi G)) M_P_full = 1.221e19 # GeV, Planck mass (1/sqrt(G)) # SM fermionic multiplicity entering the spectral action (CCM): per # generation the finite Hilbert space is 32-complex-dim (incl. nu_R, L/R, # particle/antiparticle); three generations give ~96. for label, N in [("one generation (N=32)", 32), ("three generations (N=96)", 96)]: for kappa in (1.0, 96/(24*pi**2)): # naive O(1), and CCM-like coefficient Lam_reduced = M_P_reduced / sqrt(kappa * N) Lam_full = M_P_full / sqrt(kappa * N) print(f" {label}, kappa={kappa:.3f}: " f"Lambda ~ {Lam_reduced:.2e} GeV (from M_P_red), " f"{Lam_full:.2e} GeV (from M_P)") print(""" Reading: across reasonable choices, Lambda lands in the 10^17 - 10^18 GeV band, i.e. a high unification/Planck-ish scale. This is the recognisable CCM outcome: gravity's weakness (M_P enormous) is the statement that the spectral-action cutoff Lambda is a high scale and the field content N is O(10-100). G is DERIVED from (Lambda, f, N), not posited and not obtained by Kaluza-Klein reduction. """) # ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── # §3. Replacement of the Kaluza-Klein identity; what is calibration # ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── hdr("§3 — What this replaces, and what stays calibration-dependent") print(""" Replaced (dies in the 10-foundational reading): The current PST identity G = 6 pi d_0^2 / (c r_0^2) is a Kaluza-Klein dimensional-reduction relation. With no compact spatial dimensions, it has no referent. It is replaced by the spectral-action gravitational coefficient: Einstein-Hilbert is the Lambda^2 term of Tr f(D/Lambda), G ~ 1/(f_2 Lambda^2 N). Survives, re-expressed: PST currently states G as a consistency relation among (m_h, M_P, v). The spectral action keeps G a derived quantity, now a relation among (Lambda, f-moments, field content N). The PST modal scale M_* = 4 pi m_h ~ 1.573 TeV is the natural PST-specific candidate for a low cutoff; whether the gravitational Lambda is M_* or the high unification scale above is a calibration to be fixed (the spectral action's standard running-to-unification assumption). The d_0 length scale is re-read as the LG vacuum scale, not a compactification radius. Honest status of Stage 4: - STRUCTURE (rigorous, standard CCM): the spectral action yields cosmological + Einstein-Hilbert + Yang-Mills + Higgs + Weyl^2, with G the Lambda^2 gravitational coefficient. Gravity is derived, not KK- reduced. This is the correct replacement for the dying identity. - NUMBER (calibration-dependent): the precise G requires fixing f_2, f_0, Lambda and the exact CCM normalisation; the order of magnitude (Lambda high, M_P ~ Lambda sqrt(N)) is robust and checks out (§2). - This carries the same scheme-dependence as CCM itself; PST inherits it rather than introducing new freedom. """)